Reviews
Rate Showthe best, but
i am disappointed you changed the initial music as well as your opening words. They used to set the “spell” and i sorely miss them
- Quasi andata
- June 12, 2025
A Voice for Truth
Nina is one of the most thoughtful, respectful hosts. You can tell in her episodes that she truly cares about each victim. She gives voice to victims and their families. She seeks truth and doesn't look away from injustices. Thank you for your commitment to this difficult work.
- UnsolvedAdvocay
- June 6, 2025
My favorite!!
I absolutely love Nina’s voice! And her compassion shows in her telling of each story. I’ve been listening since 2017 and don’t plan to stop! Thank you for such a great podcast.
- SuperBlargle
- May 15, 2025
Soothing
Nina’s voice is the best. She is so compassionate in her story telling. My favorite true crime podcast.
- 4doglover60
- April 10, 2025
One of my Favs
Well researched true events with great narration. There’s heart behind each episode, more than just a podcast. 🤍
- EmmyC7
- Dec. 23, 2024
Love this!
I’ve listened to EVERY episode! I love your voice, your vibe and I love this podcast!!!!!
- Helped Me!
- Nov. 29, 2024
Fabulous
I always look forward to new episodes. Nina is the most compassionate and caring host. I can only say good things about this podcast. I have been listening from the very beginning. Stories are always interesting. Thank you! I really appreciate your nonsense approach. So refreshing.
- Jersey Girl in Vermont
- Nov. 23, 2024
- gpuzzler71
- Nov. 4, 2024
Strange adds
Nina, I love the show but the ads are kinda different, mostly cause they are in a foreign language. I’m not sure how that works, but shouldn’t your audience be able to understand the adds. Ya can’t support what ya can’t understand. Well to be honest, I do think one ad was for Pizza Hut (maybe)…lol
- BBWalley
- Oct. 16, 2024
What a Pro!
Nina is a fabulous presenter! Of all the episodes of all the Podcasts I’ve heard her host & I’ve listened to every single one I’m aware of they’re amazing! Her voice is cool and perfect for what she does! I love it! It’s beautiful and unique — truly winning combination!
She does incredible research into cases that seem special to her own interests, but somehow she has a way of appealing to a wider audience.
- B•Bumpus
- Sept. 11, 2024
Weird cadence
I like the podcast… It’s interesting, but she has a weird way of talking, which is hard to ignore. And if she’s reading this, she should know that it’s supposedly not supposubly. Just saying.
- Betty Pogor
- Aug. 25, 2024
- Elliegege
- Aug. 7, 2024
Love the show! Nina is amazing
Great content from the Midwest, Nina is absolutely fantastic with her delivery and passion when narrating. I wish the podcast would release more episodes more often. Other than that great podcast.
- Ray ray sweet
- June 28, 2024
- Mrs. ReneeB
- June 26, 2024
Highly Recommend
Amazing storytelling! I’ve never been to this region of the US, but Nina can sure paint a picture. Great podcast!!
- Skza07
- May 15, 2024
Jennifer Crumbley Episode
Great discussion about Jennifer Crumbley. It was casual as you described it would be and it was thought-provoking.
- MyrnaLoyBaby
- Feb. 11, 2024
Big fan
I love hearing stories from my home state. Also, the hosts voice is so soothing and I really enjoy her storytelling.
- Lowra
- Feb. 8, 2024
Nina is the best
All the reviews where people say she’s an AI BOT or something like that are hysterical. I’ve actually met her in person and she’s not AI or a Bot. I’ve been listing at least 6 years too.
- uggggghhtimesabikkion
- Dec. 23, 2023
- kathieray
- Nov. 24, 2023
Great voice!
I fall asleep to this podcast because Nina’s voice is so calming…even though she’s talking about murder! lol! I’ve seen some of the stories she tells on true crime tv shows but I always enjoy listening to her tell it. She’s also made me want to visit Michigan.
- Lea_1967
- Nov. 18, 2023
Excellent pod from beginning to end.
There is a lot to like about this pod. Nina has an excellent voice for podcasting. Regardless of genre, she would be pleasing to the ear. She emotes as necessary, giving trigger warnings for content that is more graphic. That said, she shows empathy both to victims and their loved ones. I can contrast this to podcasts I’ve unsubscribed because frankly, the podcasters were distastefully “into” the graphic details. Lastly, the episodes are well researched and well organized so even longer episodes are clear from beginning to end. Nina also posts updates to past cases as needed.
I subscribe to a lot of podcasts with a lot eclectic tastes, but Already Gone is easily my favorite True Crime.
- Joe the Cop
- Nov. 4, 2023
Excellent
Nina has the best voice in podcasting. I discovered her by accident but I knew right away she would be a star.
- erminiver
- Oct. 29, 2023
- cswan843
- Oct. 21, 2023
- clsmks
- Oct. 18, 2023