Episodes
The Murder of Stephen McAfee - Part One
The murder of 19-year-old Stephen McAfee in March 2016. Written by Fern Bushnall. Audio Production by Bill Bert. Check out out sponsor - True Crime Podcast Training | Discover your true crime podcast career here. #Michigan #M...
The Ranes Brothers
This episode takes us to west Michigan where we explore the many crimes of Larry and Danny Ranes. Promo - The Foul Play Podcast Written by Nina Innsted. Research provided by Haley Gray. Audio production by Bill Bert. #Michiga...
The murder of Sally Weiner
The June 1988 kidnap/murder of Sally Weiner in Corry, PA. Written by Jessica Ann, audio production by Bill Bert. Check out this week's sponsor - Key to the Case Podcast . #Murder #Pennsylvania
Jennifer Crumbley Trial - BONUS
Nina is joined by Bob Motta of Defense Diaries to talk about the trial of Jennifer Crumbley. This is a casual conversation, not an in depth look at the case or the trial. #Oxford #Michigan #Trial
The murder of Cindy Zarzycki
The 1986 murder of 13 year old Cindy Zarzycki of East Detroit. Ties to cases including Kim Larrow, Kellie Brownlee, Kim King, Nadine O'Dell and others. **discussion of sexual abuse and assault, discretion advised** Written an...
Missing Mel Wiley
In the summer of 1985 police chief Mel Wiley vanished from Ohio Written by Fern Bushnall. Audio production by Bill Bert. #Missing #Ohio #Unsolved #Mystery
The murder of Justin Mello 3
October 2000. The execution-style murder of 16-year-old Justin Mello. this is part 3 of a 4 part series. Written by Jessica Ann Researched by Nina Innsted and Jessica Ann Audio Production by Bill Bert #Michigan #Murder #Macom...
The murder of Justin Mello 2
October 2000. The execution-style murder of 16-year-old Justin Mello. The case reaches its tragic conclusion. this is part 2 of a 4 part series. Written by Jessica Ann Researched by Nina Innsted and Jessica Ann Audio Producti...
Bonus Episode - True Crime Live Panel
Nina joins Amanda from Wine and Crime, Josh from True Crime Bullshi**, Robin from the Trail Went Cold, Charlie from Crimelines and Justin from Generation Why for a live panel from the Berkshires. Recorded October 2023 - defin...
The Cass Ripper
Known as the Cass Ripper, the Cass Strangler or the Big Foot killer, someone was stalking and murdering sex workers along the Cass Corridor in the 1970's #Detroit #Midtown #Michigan #unsolved Written by Nina Innsted, research...
The murder of Eileen Adams
On December 18th, 1967, 14 year old Eileen did not return home from school. It would take decades to bring justice for Eileen and her family. Caution! This episode discusses the sexual assault and murder of a child. Written b...
Murder in Springfield
The murders of Donnah Winger and Roger Harrington in Springfield IL 1995. Written by Jessica Ann. Audio production by Bill Bert. #murder #Illinois Check out our sponsor! UncommonGoods.com/alreadygone for a special savings on ...
Murder She Told - “Harold Butch Knight: Wanted for Murder”
"On Sunday, January 11th, I strangled her... she's dead, and she's laying on the living room floor... When Allegan County police showed up to the Fennville, MI residence mentioned in the haunting 911 call, they discovered the...
The murder of Jessie Blodgett
The murder of 19-year-old Jessie Blodgett in Hartford, Wisconsin, in July 2013. Written by Emily G Thompson. Editing by Bill Bert. #murder #wisconsin
The murder of Kelly Dwyer
Milwaukee WI. October 12, 2013, 27 year old Kelly Dwyer doesn't show up for work. Written by Jessica Ann. Audio Production by Bill Bert. #murder #unsolved #wisconsin Promo for our good friends at Southern Gothic .
Donald Gene Miller - revisited
This episode was written with the support of Jenn Carpenter of the podcast. Miller admitted in July 1979 to killing four women in East Lansing between Jan. 1, 1977 and Aug. 14, 1978. He was arrested on Aug. 16, 1978 after he sexually...
The Prince of Fraud
For 30-some years, Colombia-born - Michigan-raised Anthony Gignac masqueraded as a Saudi royal by the name of Prince Khalid. #scam #con #fraud #Michigan #Florida Written by Nina Innsted, researched by Haley Gray. Audio produc...
The death of Todd Stermer
January 7, 2007. Todd Stermer dies from injuries sustained in a fire at his west Michigan home. Written by Jessica Ann. Researched by Haley Gray. Audio production by Bill Bert. Support the show: https://www.patreon.com/Alread...
The murder of Nurse Pauline Campbell ** Re-release
This is a re-record and re-release of a 2017 episode. The murder of Nurse Pauline Campbell, on September 16, 1951. Researched and written by Nina Innsted, audio production by Bill Bert. #AnnArbor #Ypsilanti #Murder Support th...
Murder at Good Hart ** Re-release
This is a re-record and re-release of a 2017 episode. July 1968 - the bodies of six people, all members of the Robison family, are found in their cottage in northern Michigan. The case remains unsolved. Researched and written...
The Murder of Mujey Dumbuya
On January 24, 2018, 16-year-old Mujey Dumbuya went missing after leaving for school in the morning. Caution! This episode discusses the sexual assault and murder of a child. Listener discretion is advised. Written by Emily G...
The Brown's Chicken massacre
January 8, 1993, Palatine IL - seven people are murdered inside a Brown's Chicken. It would take nearly a decade to bring the killers to justice. Written by Jessica Ann. Researched by Haley Gray. Audio production by Bill Bert...
The Murder of Jeannie Singleton
On May 23, 1955, eight-year-old Jeannie left school on foot. She wouldn't make it home. Written by Emily Thompson, audio production by Bill Bert. #Michigan #murder #Kalamazoo
The murder of Susan Petric
On October 20, 2007 shots rang out inside the Petric home. Promo - Written by Emily Thompson, audio production by Bill Bert.