Already Gone Podcast
Great Lakes. True Crime.
Host Nina Innsted covers lesser known crimes, digging beneath the media and back page to tell their stories and find the truth. #Michigan #Ohio #Pennsylvania #NewYork #Wisconsin #Illinois #TrueCrime
The player is loading ...
Recent Episodes
Dec. 5, 2025
BONUS EPISODE - Nicole Sanchez
In September 1999, Nicole was violently murdered by her boyfriend, 23-year-old Lionel Villarreal. We spoke with her sister, who wishes to remain anonymous, to help compile this episode. Written by Charity Dodd, Audio Producti...
Dec. 1, 2025
The Oxford School Shooting
The Oxford High School shooting occurred on November 30, 2021, in Oxford Township, Michigan, when a 15-year-old student opened fire, killing four classmates and injuring seven others. The shooter and his parents were arrested...
Nov. 19, 2025
November BONUS - Author Rod Sadler
Rod Sadler is a Michigan based true crime author. Today we talk about his latest book, Depraved Obsession. HOME | Rod Sadler, Author
Nov. 15, 2025
Finishing Stacey's Fight
March 1998, Stacey Colbert doesn't show up at work, which sets a search in motion... #OSU #Ohio #Missing #murdered #unsolved Written and researched by Charity Dodd Audio production by Bill Bert Learn more here - https://www.f...
Nov. 1, 2025
The Royal Oak Post Office Shooting
On November 14, 1991, Thomas McIlvane returned to the Royal Oak Post Office after his employment was terminated. Researched by Charity Dodd, Written By Nina Innsted Audio Production by Bill Bert Check out this week's sponsor!...
Oct. 27, 2025
Bonus - Kelly Boyce Hurlbert Revisited
On July 5, 2013, Kelly Boyce Hurlbert was struck by a dark colored vehicle (possibly a truck or SUV) while riding her bike home from work in Traverse City, Michigan. Kelly was fatally injured in the incident and died at Munso...