All posts by Nina

The murder of Stephanie DuBay

In July of 1990, 15 year old Stephanie DuBay was murdered by Jaime “Jimbo” Rodriquez and his cousin, 15 year old Agustin “Auggie” Pena at the Pena home in Warren.

In 2020, Pena was released from prison after serving almost 30 years behind bars.

This episode explores what really happened that summer day in Warren when Stephanie was murdered and the community was horrified by the brutality, and possible Satanic connections to this crime.

Listen Now.

The Pelley Family Murders

Lakeview Indiana, 1989. Someone enters the home of Reverend Bob Pelley, killing Pelley, his wife and two of her children. It will take more than a decade to bring the killer to justice. 

Photo from LifeTouch Photography

This episode written by Brittany Martinez. Audio production by Gray Multimedia. 

Visit our sponsor – BetterHelp.com use code GONE at checkout for a special savings. 

Jeff’s sister believes in his innocence and has a website dedicated to freeing her brother from prison. Justice for Jeff

LISTEN NOW

Sources:

WCBI

My Crime Library

ABC News

Indianapolis Star Archives

South Bend Tribune Archives

Justia

The privacky Family Murders

November 29, 1998, the Privacky family gathers for a belated Thanksgiving celebration.


Investigators at the Privacky family home

At 6’5 Seth Privacky towers over the deputy supervising him during a court appearance.

Research provided by Haley Gray. 
Audio engineering by Gray Multimedia. 

Visit our sponsor – Better Help. Use code GONE at checkout for a special savings on your first month. 

Sources:

  1. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2018/11/question_remains_20_years_afte.html?fbclid=IwAR1Jnbct6825tN81S7z4Ybw1hAPI5tq-UN2LLY-InOErLrkqVCENomANNiw
  2. https://web.archive.org/web/20060920010029/http://www.pub.umich.edu/daily/1998/dec/12-02-98/news/news10.html
  3. https://web.archive.org/web/20070823111207/http://www.pub.umich.edu/daily/1998/dec/12-04-98/news/news14.html
  4. https://web.archive.org/web/20100719123810/http://www.woodtv.com/dpp/news/local/muskegon_county/Muskegon-murderer-shot-in-prison-break
  5. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/114069771/seth-stephen-privacky
  6. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/186700891/stephen-charles-privacky
  7. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/186700859/linda-ann-privacky
  8. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/186700837/jedediah-j.-privacky
  9. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/186700938/john-j.-privacky
  10. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/153131553/april-anne-boss
  11. https://www.genealogybank.com/doc/obituaries/obit/11552151EB69D4A0-11552151EB69D4A0?h=1&fname=stephen&lname=privacky&fullname=&rgfromDate=1998&rgtoDate=1998&formDate=&formDateFlex=exact&dateType=range&kwinc=&kwexc=&sid=evkqoucjuiaksdrdxuabswhqftwjbfyz_wma-gateway002_1605656829316
  12. https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CaseSearch/Case/C14/Detail?searchText=steven%20+%20wallace&caseId=98-042953-FH&courtType=&courtNumber=61&locationNumber=&courtSystem=2&partyTypeNumber=D1&caseType=FH&petitionNumber=null&captchaToken=03AGdBq24sjdiSmweU1dMHve3QE7TLGU_6Gk6HJs04C948Vpp1C8HRtMqqfAgFAVCnHu5eq0ORA2F5EpJHAjGflrrxKmQicNNu1OYPvUdSoNoV1yXPr4_XgPalOMzLC9lIU6QHbMix8Fgt8FfhtcnymlBHG_IPPy5g7tlWyOl50T9WiN7xa526PmtvCoyO5p405n-3P1Hxb2jLf7X1Nua5ol7sHG61ikB8DHhMOx0tc5TGvbiM7_iN_bvB5WXmEUILhVfkpOCcnxLWhyb2YSc3zmOWuUHEuhNe0-RG33r27d0K1RdneSoRDEOj_2QKeP6_PxI6KzNZANuSElxUKFfVtruLNdMA8fvvU0ARKUaOAjGG6vUJqWiHt9vMb3okiSIvEjCwfV_C3FkYdeYUUSsxEI-kZ6xFGgs2U3wbBQDaVuaOHqU4t_YyARojnniJ_hS3CIlCweCprSzfo99dvOW5CJ9g1po3r5wrzuDocpOGGCR6AYGxybSvhv9oZf7_FjXhuMVnHXEQUw3qNBwUPpSLPni1giSKfwmT9Q
  13. https://products.kitsapsun.com/archive/1998/12-03/0072_analysis__police_piece_together_a.html
  14. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/a-nightmare-in-muskegon/
  15. https://www.newspapers.com/image/100199283/?terms=seth%20privacky&match=1
  16. https://www.newspapers.com/image/522342696/?terms=seth%20privacky%20sentenced&match=1

The murder of janet Chandler

Janet Chandler

On January 31, 1979 23 year old Janet Chandler, a senior at Hope College in Holland, Michigan was kidnapped from her job at the Blue Mill Inn. Her nude body was recovered from a snowbank off I-96. It would take more than 20 years and the work of an unlikely set of researchers to bring this case back to the public eye and lead to resolution. **this case discusses a brutal act of sexual violence – listener discretion is advised** 

Sources:
Herald Palladium News Archives
Detroit Free Press News Archives
Toronto Sun
NBC News
OTIS – Michigan database
MLive



Writer – Brittney Martinez, Nina Innsted
Audio Production – Gray Multimedia 

Sponsor – Better help visit Betterhelp.com/gone and use code GONE at check out for a special savings. 
Promo – What was that like podcast. Available on you favorite podcatcher. 
#Michigan #Murder #assault #Holland #ColdCase #solved 

Listen now

The murder of Gail webster

This episode covers the unsolved murder of 48 year old Gail Webster of Troy Michigan on October 28 1978. Webster was the day shift manager of the popular Susie Q restaurant on Woodward Ave in Royal Oak. 

If you have information on Gail’s murder, Troy Police would like to hear from you. You can leave an anonymous tip at 248-524-0777

Gail Webster and her grandchild c, 1978


LISTEN NOW

Audio editing by Gray Multimedia. Our sponsor is Betterhelp. Visit Betterhelp.com and use code GONE at checkout.

Sources: Troy Police Files obtained via FOIA

#TrueCrime #Unsolved  #Murdered

Nevaeh Buchanan

Already Gone explores the May 2009 disappearance and murder of five year old Nevaeh Buchanan. Buchanan, who lived in Monroe, Michigan with her mother and grandmother disappeared Memorial Day weekend, only to be found days later in a shallow grave.

This episode researched and written by Brittney Martinez and Nina Innsted. Audio editing by Gray Multimedia. Our sponsor is Betterhelp. Visit Betterhelp.com and use code GONE at checkout. 


5 year old Nevaeh

LISTEN NOW

#TrueCrime #Unsolved #Missing #Murdered

The murder of Shannon Siders

Bob Siders worked tirelessly to find the people responsible for the death of his only child.

Shannon Siders

SOURCES:

  1. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2015/12/1989_michigan_sex_murder_solve.html
  2. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2015/05/1989_sex_murder_victims_dad_se.html
  3. https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2017/02/10/shannon-siders-murder/97775732/
  4. https://www.fox17online.com/2014/06/25/documents-reveal-details-in-shannon-siders-murder/
  5. https://cedarspringspost.com/tag/shannon-siders/
  6. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2015/04/brothers_murder_trial_starts_i.html
  7. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2012/07/exhumation_of_1989_newaygo_cou.html
  8. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2011/12/shannon_siders_father_reliving.html
  9. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2012/10/reburial_of_newaygo_homicide_v.html
  10. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2014/06/2_brothers_arrested_in_connect.html
  11. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2014/09/first_testimony_in_hearing_on.html
  12. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2014/09/judge_finds_probable_cause_new.html
  13. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2014/09/free_to_go_decision_looms_on_1.html
  14. https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/local/2015/04/22/witnesses-tell-finding/26183599/
  15. https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4348133/people-of-michigan-v-paul-michael-jones/
  16. http://mdocweb.state.mi.us/OTIS2/otis2profile.aspx?mdocNumber=960702
  17. http://mdocweb.state.mi.us/OTIS2/otis2profile.aspx?mdocNumber=514868
  18. https://www.genealogybank.com/doc/obituaries/obit/1420AF8EB63F7F38-1420AF8EB63F7F38?h=1&fname=shannon&lname=siders&fullname=&rgfromDate=&rgtoDate=&formDate=&formDateFlex=exact&dateType=range&kwinc=&kwexc=&sid=mlvkofbqxpeqnmdllzuimvdbkjxzzdcd_wma-gateway010_1597617890186
  19. https://micourt.courts.michigan.gov/CaseSearch/
  20. https://www.mlive.com/news/muskegon/2015/04/murder_trial_of_brothers_under.html
  21. On the Case with Paula Zahn –
    Into the Dark
  22. Cold Case File

The Rutherford/Stempien case

In August 2005, Lana Stempien and her boyfriend, Chuck Rutherford set off for Mackinaw Island in Lana’s boat, the Sea’s Life. Within 48 hours both of them were missing and Sea’s Life was found adrift in Lake Huron. We explore the disappearance and mystery surrounding the events of this trip. 

Special thanks to Samantha Taylor for giving voice to Lana Stempien
Written by Nina Innsted 
Researched by Haley Gray
Audio production and music by Gray Multimedia


Fox News Specials - Crime Scene: Dark Waters - Clip from Season 1
The Sea’s Life – adrift

https://omny.fm/shows/already-gone/missing-in-michigan-rutherford-stempien-2005

THe murder of Florence Unger

n 2003, Florence Unger was a wife and mother, with two beautiful sons living in a nice part of suburban Detroit. If you looked a little closer you could see cracks in the foundation of the family, her husband’s addiction issues, her struggle to provide for the boys and keep the family together. 

Just weeks after she filed for divorce, Florence was dead, her body floating in the water, yards from the up north cottage she was staying in with her husband and children. 


#Michigan #Murder #Benzie #UpNorth 

This episode written by Brittany Martinez. Audio editing by Gray Multimedia.

Special promo – Crimelines True Crime Podcast.


https://omny.fm/shows/already-gone/the-murder-of-florence-unger

Elias Abuelazam

E’twan Wilson survived his encounter with Abuelazam, but has many scars to show for it.


19 year old Davon Rawls survived an attack by Abuelazam,

In the summer of 2010 the community of Flint, Michigan was stalked by a knife wielding man who focused his murderous rage primarily on Black men in the community. When he was taken in to custody, he left more than a dozen gravely injured men and five deaths in his wake.

This episode explores the life and many crimes of serial killer Elias Abuelazam.


Abuelazam in a mugshot from Virginia, August 2010.

Listen Now

Missing in MIchigan – Paige Renkoski

On May 24, 1990. Paige Renkoski drove her mother to the airport, she stopped and visited a friend. After that she parked her car on the shoulder of I-96, exited the car leaving behind her purse and shoes. Paige Renkoski vanished. She has never been seen or heard from again. Join Already Gone as we explore one of the most compelling missing person’s cases in Michigan history. 

LISTEN NOW

Paige wearing the same clothing she had on the day of her disappearance.



This episode was primarily compiled using interviews with family and investigators. Additional sources:

Ardis Renkoski – Find a Grave

Livingston Daily 2015

Detroit Free Press